Skip to main content

Juvenile Legislation - Neuroscience and beyond

3 years back, Nirbhaya case created a stir in society as it saw a lower abyss in society. 6 persons were convicted for the heinous crime of rape, one of them was a juvenile. The  same juvenile created another stir when he walked out of juvenile rehabilitation home in December 2015. Icing to the cake of stirs was amendment of Juvenile Justice Act which added the provision that a juvenile of age between 16 to 18 be treated as adult for heinous crimes.

Though this amendment has been criticized, but most peculiar and scientific criticism has come from Neuroscience professionals.

They argue that the part called frontal lobe - the front part of the brain, is underdeveloped at the age between 16-18. This is the part which is responsible for decision making, impulse control, judgement and emotions. They further argue that in the condition of stress, the same frontal lobe shrinks losing their capacity to process information. In turn, the back of brain Amygdala - which is responsible for fear, anxiety and aggression - increases. To further strengthen their point, they say that the age of adulthood of 18 is arbitrary and has no relation with maturity.

But, I would say, sex is a physiological requirement which start popping in around the age of adolescence which overlap with the age of 16-18. Secondly, justice system must take into consideration of the victims and stop going soft on the culprit just because he is yet to complete 18 years in a couple of months. The amendment is for heinous crimes and not all crimes. Further, if go by  neuroscientists logic, a person is not mature even at the age of 24, and even 36. But a big chunk of crimes are committed by these age groups.

While forming a law, many aspects are to be taken into consideration. There can be social aspect, psychological aspect (which the neuroscientst are putting), cultural and economic aspect, demographic aspect etc. Many a times in crime, one aspect pre-dominate than the other. No neuroscience report/research has come up saying the Nirbhaya juvenile rapist had some neuro-disorder. It was actually a social disorder which need to be rectified.

Its more of lack of social responsibility and value which leads to such crimes than neurological issue.

Everybody has animal inside, how efficiently and effectively one tames it is what makes him human.

Article link: Neuroscience and the juvenile legislation

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The legacy of Srinivasa Ramanujan

His work has had a fundamental role in the development of 20th century mathematics and his final writings are serving as an inspiration for the mathematics of this century On a height he stood that looked towards greater heights. Our early approaches to the Infinite Are sunrise splendours on a marvellous verge While lingers yet unseen the glorious sun. What now we see is a shadow of what must come. Sri Aurobindo, Savitri, 1.4 The story of Srinivasa Ramanujan is a 20th century “rags to mathematical riches” story. In his short life, Ramanujan had a wealth of ideas that have transformed and reshaped 20th century mathematics. These ideas continue to shape mathematics of the 21st century. This article seeks to give a panoramic view of his essential contributions. Born on December 22, 1887 in the town of Erode in Tamil Nadu, Ramanujan was largely self-taught and emerged from extreme poverty to become one of the most influential mathematicians of the 20th c...

Why Bodo Violence Continues to Recur?

December 29, 2014 The Bodo areas in Assam are witnessing bloodshed once again. The National Democratic Front of Bodoland (Songbijit faction) [NDFB-S] is alleged to have targeted the  Adivasi  settlers in the two districts of Sonitpur and Kokrajhar, killing nearly 78 and leaving many seriously injured. It appears that this carnage started in retaliation to the death of three NDFB (S) cadres during a counter-insurgency operation conducted by the Mahar Regiment on December 21 against the outfit’s camp in the Chirang District along the Assam-Bhutan border. Information from the ground reveal that the NDFB-S may have targeted the  Adivasi  settlers near the forest areas suspecting them of providing intelligence about their movement to the counter-insurgency forces. The faction is known to have regularly targeted people both from Bodo and non-Bodo ethnicities on suspicion of being police informants, like the case of a 16-year old Bodo school girl who was dragg...

Aadhaar : Key Features

The National Identification Authority of India (NIAI) will issue identification number (called "Aadhaar" number) to residents of India and any other category of people that may be specified. The NIAI shall have a chairperson and two part-time members. Aadhaar Numbers Every resident of India (regardless of citizenship) shall be entitled to obtain an Aadhaar number after furnishing demographic and biometric information. Demographic information shall include items such as name, age, gender and address. Biometric information shall include some biological attributes of the individual. Collection of information pertaining to race, religion, caste, language, income or health is specifically prohibited. The Aadhaar number shall be issued after the information provided by the person is verified. It shall serve as proof of identity, subject to authentication. However, it should not be construed as proof of citizenship or domicile. The Aadhaar number holder may be required t...